Joy of Knowing Your Body Fat Percentage
#2 - Water weighs about 8 pounds per gallon. Many people (of the heavier variety) can experience this much weight fluctuation in a day. That weight will show up on the scales and may either excite you (if you are dehydrated), or depress you (if you are well-hydrated). Losing water weight does not necessarily equate to losing body fat. Skinfold measurements combined with weighing yourself is the preferred method.
I've measured thousands of peoples body fat over the past couple of decades and still use the same measuring device. The following will give you an idea of why I prefer AccuMeasure skinfold calipers.
Arent Electrical Body Fat Testers More Accurate?
The December 1998 issue of the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, "Validity of Self-Assessment Techniques for Estimating Percent Fat in Men and Women," key findings included the following:
Self-testing of percent body fat with the AccuMeasure was as accurate as results from multi-site measurements and calculations taken by an experienced clinical investigator using a Lange caliper. [Lange is the expensive hand-held metal device we used in college under controlled clinical settings]. Percent body fat calculations with the AccuMeasure were within 1.1 percentage points of underwater weighing results, the gold standard of body fat measurement. AccuMeasure was recommended over another self-assessment device, the Futrex-1000, which significantly overestimated percent body fat.
The researchers also mentioned in the Journal: "A salient feature of the AccuMeasure is that it is an inexpensive self-assessment technique that requires little skill to administer, therefore offering an attractive alternative for individuals who wish to determine their body composition without the inconvenience, expense, and lack of privacy of conventional body fat testing at clinics or recreational facilities."
The Body Logic Fat Analyzer from Omron and the Body Fat Monitor / Scale from Tanita send a low-voltage current through the body. Devices such as these measure how much body tissues impede the flow of electrical current. They DO NOT measure actual body fat content. In a study sponsored by the National Institute of Health (NIH), scientists at the National Institute of Standards and Technology found that impedance measurements made by six different commercial instruments varied by as much as 40% from the actual impedance of known standards. According to the New York Times, "an impedance result for someone will not accurately predict body-fat content unless it is compared with the results of people who are similar in various ways like age, weight, sex, height and athleticism and who have also been tested with some more accurate measuring tool." Other factors affect impedance such as body positioning during testing, hydration status, recent consumption of food and beverages, ambient air and skin temperatures, and recent physical activity. The New York Times found results varied on a tester from 16 to 27% body fat -- too inconsistent for a person serious about body fat management.
Isnt the Body Mass Index
a Better Measurement Indicator for Body Fat?
What are some of the health
risks with having too much body fat?
Nutrition Home Page
The information and statements made throughout this web site have not been endorsed/evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration or any other governmental authority, unless otherwise specifically noted. We do not offer products or services for the benefits or purpose of diagnosis, prescription for, treatment of, or claims to prevent, mitigate or cure any viral or disease condition or be free from side effects. Please, seek the advice of a competent medical professional about anything you read on our site.RSS Feed