New York Becomes First U.S. City to Ban Trans Fat
The ban might pressure some restaurants to resort to using unhealthy saturated fats instead, association spokeswoman Sue Hensley said.
"There is also a legal concern about a city municipal health agency banning an ingredient that the Food and Drug Administration has already approved," she said.
New York's measure, unanimously approved by the city Board of Health, requires restaurants to stop using most frying oils containing artificial trans fat within about 6 months and to keep it out of all foods by July 2008.
"New Yorkers overwhelmingly favor action to get artificial trans fat out of their restaurants," Health Commissioner Thomas Frieden said.
He said the rules were designed with a more relaxed deadline and grace periods to accommodate restaurant owners who complained that an earlier proposal did not give them enough time.
The ban does not apply to grocery stores or the foods restaurants serve in sealed original packaging. It also does not include naturally occurring trans fats found in small amounts in some meat and dairy products.
Most artificial trans fat is in partially hydrogenated vegetable oil, which is used for baking and frying and is found in many processed foods. Those trans fats also are in margarine and some shortenings.
This means New York restaurants will have to use alternatives as they serve everything from fried chicken and pies to hamburger buns and pizza dough.
Doctors and scientists widely agree that artificial trans fats, invented to be a healthier and longer-lasting alternative to natural animal fats such as butter, are dangerous in almost any amount. They are viewed as more unhealthy than saturated fats because they raise bad cholesterol while lowering good cholesterol.
Willett said governments have a responsibility to ban them.
"If somebody was in the kitchens in the restaurants of New York dumping arsenic into hamburger mix, there would be an outrage if the public health department didn't do anything about it," he said. "This is really not any different."
The FDA this year began requiring that packaged foods list trans fat content on nutrition labels. Many manufacturers have since changed their products to have "zero grams" of trans fat, which is defined by the government as meaning less than half a gram per serving.
The New York restaurant ban uses a similar standard.
In Chicago, proposed trans fat restrictions aimed at large fast-food chains would apply only to companies with revenues of more than $20 million each year.
Several companies already have moved to eliminate trans fat from products.
McDonald's Corp. has used trans fat-free cooking oil in Denmark since that country banned the fats. The company is experimenting with healthier oils for use in the United States and says it will be ready for New York's deadlines.
Wendy's International Inc. said in August that it switched to a new cooking oil without trans fats. YUM! Brands Inc.'s KFC plans to cut trans fat by April by switching to a new soybean oil.
Nutrition Home Page
The information and statements made throughout this web site have not been endorsed/evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration or any other governmental authority, unless otherwise specifically noted. We do not offer products or services for the benefits or purpose of diagnosis, prescription for, treatment of, or claims to prevent, mitigate or cure any viral or disease condition or be free from side effects. Please, seek the advice of a competent medical professional about anything you read on our site.RSS Feed